For a long time, I thought being nice, being kind, and being agreeable were sort of more or less the same thing.
I wanted to treat people well, to be respectful, and to be someone others enjoyed being around. I mean, who doesn’t want that? As gregarious beings, we tend to look for social acceptance. You don’t get that by being mean to others.
Somewhere along the way, and because of that, I also learned to keep a lot of what I thought to myself. Looking back, now I can see how easily those things can become tangled.
Free weekly reflections for sustainable discipline.
Straight to your inbox.
Learning to Stay Quiet
Growing up, I was taught to respect my elders. I guess probably every kid in my generation was taught that: to respect and obey blindly. “Because I say so,” “you don’t get to talk back,” and “apologize” are some of the phrases that become staples as you grow. The thing is, realistically, our parents didn’t know more than we know now at the same age. We are trying to do better because society has evolved as well. They did the best they could. So I don’t judge my parents for that.
My dad had to work in another town, so on top of that mindset, there was the idea that I had to help my mom. Not in a crazy way, but as the older sibling I believed that I had to be a good example and help with the little things I could. One of them was not causing trouble.
At school, there were times when a teacher would speak to me in a way that felt demeaning, and I would stay quiet. I had to respect my elders, and I didn’t want to give my mom a headache.
I remember feeling powerless.
I wanted to say something, but I also worried about what would happen afterward. Would speaking up make me disrespectful? Would the teachers decide I was the problem? Would my mom think I was the problem?
So I just sucked it up. The teacher would have their say, the class moved on, and I was left with whatever I hadn’t said. In middle school, there was this teacher who would make fun of the fact that I asked too many questions. There was another teacher who would make fun of me in front of the class because I was one of the only kids who didn’t know how to play the flute.
I think that was the first time my dad tried to teach me to break the status quo and advised me to tell the teacher to “shove the flute up his a**.” Of course I didn’t, hahaha. How would I want to be trouble?
And look at that. I felt compelled to stay quiet, even though I had my dad’s blessing. Sort of, LOL.
As you can see, when you’re young, you’re still learning what respect looks like. The adults around you have a lot of influence over that definition. In my case, I got plenty of practice through reminders to be helpful, comply, and keep the peace.
Of being good.
I had much less practice saying that something bothered me while still treating the other person with respect. Staying quiet was more comfortable, even when it could impact me somehow.
Those habits followed me as I grew older. They followed me in school, with friends, and in relationships. It was hard; setting boundaries was something foreign to me, and it felt like too much effort to even try. Bailing and sneaking out of a relationship — taking the easy road — was way more tempting because it was easier.
As time went by, I became more aware of how often I was considering someone else’s reaction before I had even figured out what I wanted to say.
After moving to the U.S., I came across a book called No More Mr. Nice Guy, by Robert Glover. I had already started noticing some of these patterns in myself, and the book gave me language to examine them and an ice-cold bucket of water to wake me up.
Why was being liked so important to me?
How much of what I called being nice involved hiding a preference, avoiding a disagreement, or hoping that giving enough would lead someone to respond the way I wanted?
To be frank, those were really fucking uncomfortable questions — and pardon my French, but I want to highlight how hard it is to admit that — especially because I still valued kindness. My whole identity was built around being the smart, nice guy who always agreed and meant no problem. The good boy. But it was true. I still wanted to keep caring about people and treating them well, but I also needed to understand why my own feelings so often ended up outside the conversation. Figuring out the distinction between these words — kind, nice, and agreeable — started to matter to me.
When Nice, Kind, and Agreeable Get Tangled
I do think I have a better picture of the difference now, and I think you might resonate with it: when I think of being nice, I think of being pleasant and considerate in how I interact with someone; being agreeable, on the other hand, brings in a willingness to go along, accommodate, and find common ground; kindness asks me to care about how I treat people and how my actions affect them.
These concepts sound very similar, which makes their conflation understandable. But they are not the same, and I think it’s important to learn how to use them, and most importantly, how to embody them, when it corresponds.
In my opinion, these three traits still earn their place. The problem with intertwining them lies, I’d say, in when going along becomes so automatic that we barely pause to consider what we’re agreeing to. Before, I wouldn’t stop and assess what I was trying to do, and most importantly, why. I would just ignore myself and agree to whatever, or worse, ignore the other person or their tone and try to keep the peace.
Recently I discovered the term self-silencing, which helped me name that reaction. It’s when you feel or want to say something, but hold it back because you’re worried about the other person’s reaction. Basically, what we usually call “walking on eggshells.” In the eyes of an external observer, the interaction would look perfectly normal, but it would miss the part we didn’t want to say, which is usually the most important because, in some cases, it violates our boundaries.
As I mentioned, I used to self-silence a lot. Now, older, I’ve learned to separate these concepts and hold my ground while caring about how I treat others — being kind — rather than only being agreeable or sounding nice.
Not being able to hold my ground and set boundaries took a toll on me, and probably, if you are reading this, you might feel identified.
Has it happened to you that sometimes you commit to something you don’t want to do just because you don’t want to cause trouble or complicate things?
Well, it happened to me a lot. I would commit to things I didn’t want to do and then dread doing them. I would agree with feedback I didn’t understand or wouldn’t ask more questions out of fear that I could be considered troublesome.
At some point, I started looking around and noticed that I had teammates who weren’t afraid to say no or who didn’t mind giving tough feedback because they cared.
During my time at Amazon, I came across the book Radical Candor, and it really opened my mind to the idea that I can still hold my ground and challenge others while caring about them. It turns out that it doesn’t only help at work, but in life in general. I really recommend that book.
Surprisingly — at least for me — once you start doing this, you really lift a weight off your shoulders, and things start making sense. Everything around you starts making sense. At least that’s how it was for me. Once I realized that I could forge my own path, I started being more intentional about my words, my relationships, and my feelings.
Now, it wasn’t easy. For me it was a live experiment: tuning and learning. I’d go to the other extreme, not giving space to grow, not accepting challenges, and holding my ground unnecessarily. That has consequences, and it impacts others too. So it’s important to understand that while holding your ground and not letting the influence of others quickly guide your choices is important, we still have to be critical thinkers and accept other people’s challenges when it’s due.

👉 Want to actually train this, not just read it?
Each week inside Discipline Circle, I publish a short Paid Companion you can work through in 10 minutes on a slow day, so the idea sticks when a hard day hits.
$9.99/month.

What Boundaries Ask of Us
Because of that, I’ve also started paying more attention to why and when I compromise. Sometimes I’ve thought something through and accepted somebody else’s input. Other times, I’m just tired of the tension or feel anxious about disappointing the other person. I’m human, after all. In both cases, I might end up making the same concession, but I would feel very differently about each one.
Moments like these are good opportunities to also challenge yourself: What matters to me here? What am I willing to adjust? What do I need the other person to understand?
These questions move around one concept: boundaries.
For me, boundaries begin with those questions. Before I can communicate a limit clearly, I need to know what I’m trying to protect and why it matters. I need to internalize it, so later I’m able to vocalize it and enforce it, and allow the other person to have a response and decide how to respond to it.
But as I said, there is also another responsibility in that conversation. I have to be willing to examine my own behavior.
At work, for example, I might receive feedback in a way that feels dismissive. I could get annoyed with how someone spoke to me and still spend time considering what they said. If I value being reliable and they point out somewhere I’ve fallen short, that deserves my attention. I can ask for respect while also taking responsibility and holding myself accountable for that.
This is where coherence enters the game. My values have to guide both the boundaries I set and the changes I’m willing to make. That means sometimes speaking up for something I’ve been minimizing. Sometimes it means hearing something uncomfortable, sucking it up, and admitting that I have work to do.
When we set a path we want to follow, it makes it easier to return to it, but it takes constant practice. Sometimes we will drift, in this case in the shape of self-silencing or not wanting to take action on the changes we need to make. But as long as we keep practicing, those moments will become less frequent, and setting boundaries and accepting challenges will become a habit.
In our next paid companion, we will help you practice returning when you find yourself in situations where holding a boundary is hard, especially when the conditions make it easier for drift to pull you away.
For what it’s worth, I still care about being considerate. I want to leave my kids that example. Now the difference is that before I automatically agree, I want to give myself enough room to ask myself a simple question.
Have I actually said what I think?
I hope you have a wonderful week!

✨ Ideas Worth Exploring
If this piece resonated, here are a few more that go hand-in-hand.






